AP Research Performance Task Sample and Scoring Information Archive

Download sample Academic Papers along with scoring guidelines and scoring distributions.

If you are using assistive technology and need help accessing these PDFs in another format, contact Services for Students with Disabilities at 212-713-8333 or by email at [email protected] .  

placeholder

PDF Word LaTeX

PDF Word LaTeX Github

MR. NELSON'S BUSINESS STATISTICS

Andrew Nelson of Granada Hills Charter High School Presents

Site Navigation [Skip]

AP CAPSTONE

RUBRIC REVIEW #1

Sample Peer Reviewed Paper - Good Generic Model

Sample Peer Reviewed Paper - Another Good Generic Model

LINKS  To AP Research Materials, Assignments, Deadlines

Prerequisite Skills

Statistics Page

Bibliography & Literature Review Materials

Inquiry Proposal Form & PREP

Analysis of Data/Findings

Capstone Academic Research Paper

Presentation & Oral Defense

AP Research Workbook   (List of Methods Page 98)  

Library of Congress Subject Headings (LOCSH) On-line Catalog

LOCSH Alphabetical PDF Lists

Vanessa’s Data

***********************************************************

HALL OF FAME PAPERS - #5 score places you among the best of the best

Here are the six “5" papers from 2019 as judged by College Board:

Perception of Women in Leadership

By Rachel Feldman 19’ 

Self-Affirmation as a Stress Buffer in High School Student’s Cognitive Ability 

By Denice Higareda, 19'

General Perceived Self-Efficacy and the Struggles of Test Anxiety 

By  Gabby Holquin, 19'

The Effects of School Resource Officers on Feelngs of School Connectedness and Safety 

By Stephanie Mier, 19'

Determining the Factors that Influence One’s Opinions on Globalization Within Youth 

By Zareh Shahinian, 19'

Adolescent Exposure to Sad Music 

By Jessica Wong, 19'

Here are the eight “5" papers from 2018 as judged by College Board:

Personality and Tempo: Exploring the Relationship Between   Music and Cognition           

By Matthew Bacon, 18'

Gender Differences in Attitudes Towards   STEM Among High School Students                     

  By Alexis Bui, 18'

Human Evaluation of Machine Translation   

By Tanvi Kharkar, 18'

Parasocial Relationships: A Study Concerning Adolescents Media Engagement

& Interaction   By Cambria Meadows, 18'

The Acting White Accusation: an examination of academic achievement, perceived educational benefits, and peer influence among high school students    By Success Ufondo, 18’

Relationship Between Factors of Behavior &  Length of Stay in Dogs Housed in A No Kill Animal Shelter      

By John Wargowski, 18’

Placebo Sleep and Student Cognition: Examining the Power of Perception            

By Ethan Trunfio, 18’

What are High School Students Attitudes and Opinions Towards Physician Assisted Suicide?  

By Madina Safdari, 18'

Here are five “perfect" scores from 2017 as judged by College Board:

Youth Impulsivity Levels: Disordered Gambling & Substance Absue     By Diane Bui, 17'

A Study of Aesthetics and Hedonics in Photography      By Bria Rosenberg, 17’

Consequences of Texting Behaviors on Teen Romantic Relationships   By Goldy Faramarzyan, 17 ’

Paper By Valeria Robles, 17’ Coming Soon.

Here are three other “5" scores from 2017 as judged by College Board:

Effect of Dog Interactions on High School Students Mood & Anxiety   - By Anam, 17'

Hope’s Word Use in the Poetry of Anne Saxrton & Sylvia Plath   - By Hope Su, 17’

Korean Ethnic Identity & Assimiliation Levels of High School Students in an Ethinically Diverse Calfironia School   - By Esther Lee, 17'

Daring Sample Paper Employing A Delphi Research Method

A Study on Societal Attitudes Towards Terraforming Mars     By Nick Turcios, 17’   (BEWARE!!)

Course Introduction Materials

2018-9 AP Research Student Workbook  

2018-9 AP Research Course Two-Page Description

2018-9 AP Research Course & Exam Description Effective 2017

Moving From Preliminary Research To Literature Review

Research Notecard Template (Google Doc)

Mr. Nelson’s Opening Comments

AP Research Advice Highlights Capstone Class of 2017

AP Research Senior Advice To Juniors Excel All Responses

College Board Plagiarism Policy

Falsification & Fabrication  

Digital Portfolio Account Set-up

account.collegeboard.org/login/login

apcapstoneportfolio.collegeboard.org

  Student Account Set-up Instructions

media.collegeboard.com/digitalServices/pdf/ap/ap-capstone/ap-capstone-digital-portfolio-student-user-guide.pdf

Resume/LinkedIn Description

AP Seminar and AP Research are two innovative new courses that are at the heart of College Board’s Capstone diploma program.  To receive the Capstone diploma, students must receive a three or higher in both AP Seminar and AP Research , and receive a three or higher on four other AP exams. The Capstone program teaches the broad set of skills required to write publishable, academic research papers.  The following inventories the specific skills that I developed through Capstone .

·              Perform aligned research of peer-reviewed academic literature. 

·              Design research methods that align with past research.

·              Collect data relevant to an aligned research topic.

·              Curate quantitative and qualitative findings and analyze results.

·              Report key findings, conclusions and recommendations for future research.

·              Received a top score of “5 “in AP Seminar , a score attained by only 6% of all course participants.)  (Received a score of “4 “in AP Seminar , ranking in the top quarter of Capstone students worldwide.)

Get a recommendation statement (NOT A LETTER) from your Seminar teacher. 

Everyone in your GBF class endorse you for Research Skills.

FALL FINAL MATERIAL REQUIREMENTS  - Students must bring the following items to class on Wednesday, the day of final.  Deductions will be made for missing items.  Thank you.

TEACHER NOTES:

College Board on Falsification

Sample Oral Defense Presentation Slides

Denise’s Draft Slides

Vanessa’s Draft Slides

*********************************************

PRELIMINARY ORAL DEFENSE PRESENTATION SCHEDULE

Saturday April 13  7:30-11:00AM

7:30am - 9:00am  Denice H, Gabby H, Daniel V

9:00am - 10:30am  Zareh S,  Stephanie M, Evana D

Thursday April 11, 2019 3:30-6:00PM

3:30pm - 5:00pm  Dakota E, Aaron C, Victoria D

4:30pm - 6:00pm Angel N, Melia L

Wednesday April 10, 2019 3:30-6:00PM  

3:30pm - 5:00pm  Stacy B, Jessica W., Vanessa F

  4:30pm - 6:00pm  Camille J, David Y

****************************************************

MONDAY Presenters - Dakota, Stephanie

TUESDAY Presenters - Jessica, Rachel

Victoria Thursday Lunch

WEDNESDAY Presenters - David, Evans, Denice

THURSDAY Presenters - Stacy, Gabby, Camille

Zee, Victoria - Thursday Lunch

FRIDAY Presenters - Melia, Daniel, Aaron

Angel - Friday Lunch

AP Research Sample Papers: 

Autoimune Disease

Time for Dinner

Prompt Questions For Assessing Papers Above

Anam’s Paper   - Effect of Dog Interactions on High School Students Mood & Anxiety

Hope’s Paper   - Word Use in the Poetry of Anne Saxton & Sylvia Plath

Katie’s Paper   - Tear Analysis of Contact Lenses Using A Cell-Phone Based Fluorometric Assay Reader

Esther’s Paper - Korean Ethnic Identity & Assimilation Levels of High School Students in an Ethnically Diverse Californian High School

Diane’s Paper  -  Youth Impulsivity Levels: Disordered Gambling & Substance Abuse

A Study of Aesthetics and Hedonics in Photography     By Bria Rosenberg, 17’ (See Methods Section)

CONFIDENCE INTERVALS: Algebra 2 Hand-out That Explain Calculation & Interpretation of Confidence Intervals

Financial Incentives & Student Achievement

Ivan’s Monday Class Example

Bria’s Monday Class Example

Statistical Findings Worksheet

Student Sample IPF - Thank You Melissa

Sampling Survey Example: Attitudes Towards the LGBT Community Survey  - Thanks to Melissa  

Organizing Your Social Sciences Research Paper: Purpose of Guide

USC Research Guide - Set of articles that guide first-time students through the research process.

What Librarians Use To Create Research Pathfinders ,  Much Thanks To LE Spears  August 2017

Academic Research Databases  

August 22 SAMPLE LITERATURE:  IMPROVING IN-KENNEL PRESENTATION OF SHELTER DOGS THROUGH RESPONSE-DEPENDENT AND RESPONSE-INDEPENDENT TREAT DELIVERY

SAMPLE LITERATURE #2

SAMPLE LITERATURE #3

Challenge and Opportunity in Evaluating a Diffusion-Based Active Bystanding Prevention Program: Green Dot in High Schools  

eHow:  How to Use the Likert Scale in Statistical Analysis

How To Use Data, Artificial Scales (e.g. Likert)

Jamie’s Survey

Diane’s Survey

Methods Outline Assignment

Processing & Organizing Your Data In Excel Worksheets

Chi Square Tests Example Excel

Solid Khan Video On Chi Suqare Test May Help Some

Survey Outline Example

Example: Final Results

Word Format Outline of Methods Section

2017 Candidates DO NOT USE FORM BELOW - USE THE ONE AT TOP OF PAGE

GUIDELINES FOR INQUIRY PROPSAL FORM PRESENTATION

Mr. Wolf’s Checklists By Report Section

Mr. Wolf   Introduction Checklist

Mr. Wolf   Methods Checklist

Mr. Wolf   Findings, Analysis, Results Checklist

Mr. Wolf   Conclusion Checklist

ap capstone research paper example

Class Information

Parent Letter

Course Detailed Syllabus    AP Course Description / Standards

Course and Exam Description.pdf (from CollegeBoard)

AP Research Summer Work

Research Paper Rubric.pdf (2018-present)

Course Proficiencies Rubric Outline.pdf (2017-present)

Presentation and Oral Defense Rubric.pdf (2017-present)

Oral Defense Questions.pdf (UPDATED)

Google Scholar: https://scholar.google.com

Cambridge Core: https://www.cambridge.org/core

Oxford Journals: http://www.oxfordjournals.org/en

Springer: http://link.springer.com

ERIC: https://eric.ed.gov/?advanced

Wilson Center: http://wilsoncenter.org

National Center for Biotechnology Information: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

100 Search Engines For Academic Research .pdf

Research Design Textbook.pdf

Research Website Guides

USC Libraries Research Guides: http://libguides.usc.edu

Purdue OWL Research: https://owl.english.purdue.edu/research

Social Science Statistics Home Page: http://www.socscistatistics.com

Citation Style by Discipline

University Library: American University

USC Libraries: Citation Guide

Subject-Specific Resources: Purdue Online Writing Lab

Types of Educational Research: Website

Statistics (Videos)

Annenberg Learner Website: Against All Odds: Inside Statistics

AP Central - AP Research Course Home Page: http://bit.ly/2aPAqsi

TED Talks: https://www.ted.com

Educational TED Talks: http://ed.ted.com

Types of Methods.pdf

http://www.socialresearchmethods.net/kb/stat_t.php

Harry Potter Example Paper.pdf

T-Test Link #1    T-Test Link #2

Class Readings and Handouts

Why so many people sleep in McDonald's in Hong Kong - CNN.pdf

Greenland Has The World's Highest Suicide Rate...: NPR.pdf    weblink: http://n.pr/1TkUCT5

Time trend by region of suicides and suicidal thoughts among Greenland Inuit.pdf

Facing History webpage for Race and Membership Book (scroll to the bottom of the page)

AP Research Topics for 2016.xlsx

Vaccines and Autism Article.pdf

Jenny McCarthy Article    YouTube Video

Do these sources work with PAARC? Which one is best source?

• Why do Koreans prefer apartments over private houses?    PDF Version

• Why dream of a high-rise apartment?    PDF Version

• After Decades of Economic Growth, South Korea is the Land of Apartments    PDF Version

Beginning Your Research.pdf

Understanding the IRB.pdf

Inquiry Proposal Form.docx    Inquiry Proposal Form.pdf

Training Sample Papers

Training Sample 1.pdf

Training Sample 2.pdf

Training Sample 3.pdf

Training Sample 4.pdf

Training Sample 5.pdf

Student Research Paper Samples

Student Sample #1.pdf                         Sample #1 2017.pdf

Student Sample #2.pdf                         Sample #2 2017.pdf

Student Sample #3.pdf                         Sample #3 2017.pdf

Student Sample #4.pdf                         Sample #4 2017.pdf

Student Sample #5.pdf                         Sample #5 2017.pdf

Student Sample #6.pdf                         Sample #6 2017.pdf

Student Sample #7.pdf

Student Sample #8.pdf

HHS Research Paper Samples

NOTE: Your name is never on the paper when it is submitted. On the title page is only your title and word count .

1- High School Foreign Language Education.pdf (survey example)

2- Food Deserts.pdf (content analysis, defining)

3- ADHD and Comorbidity.pdf (content analysis)

4-.Speech,Gender,Politicspdf.pdf (content analysis, and video research)

AP Digital Portfolio Student User Guide for AP Capstone

ap capstone research paper example

Redwood High School

Search

Welcome to our main page. Here you will find announcements, resources, calendar of events and useful links for our course

AP Research year 4 - 2020-2021

Emily LaTourrette, Ernesto Diaz, & Christy Stocker

AP Research Syllabus:  File containing the current version of our syllabus

AP Research Intro VIDEO

AP Research  is open to students who have successfully completed AP Seminar in their Junior year. What makes this course interesting? During the year, you will be exposed to a myriad of research methods used in different fields and adapt those that will benefit your own research project. In the course you will design, plan, and conduct a year-long, research-based investigation to address a research question of interest to you. It provides the opportunity to learn and apply research methods and practices in a field that addresses a real-world topic of your choosing. While working with an expert advisor, you can explore an academic topic, problem, or issue that interests you and design, plan, and conduct a year-long research-based investigation to address it. The class is designed to be broken in three major parts. The first section is centered in choosing the topic and specific research project. In the second section you engage in the different activities associated with answering the question chosen as your research project and work towards the presentation of your investigation, results and conclusions from your research. In the last section the course culminates not in an Exam, but rather in the delivery of an academic paper of 4,000-5,000 words and a presentation, with an oral defense, during which you will answer 3-4 questions from a panel of evaluators

  Questions about AP Research? Please contact Ernesto Diaz  [email protected]  or Christy Stocker  [email protected]  or Emily LaTourrette (currently on leave of absence)  [email protected]  

 The College Board’s AP Research web site also has a wide range of information about the course for students and parents at https://apstudent.collegeboard.org/apcourse/ap-research

 Lecture  Introduction to Research

AP Capstone Program at Redwood High School

Useful resources, documents, and websites:

Link to  AP Central   for the course and assessment descriptions

Link to Google  Scholar

Link to EBSCO  http://tiny.cc/RedwoodLibraryEBSCOall

Guidelines: Did I plagiarize?

Link to  Plato  - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Link:   http://tiny.cc/RedwoodLibraryEBSCOall   (your one-stop link to credible (authoritative) science / literary / history… sources) 

User Name : Redwoodhs

Password : Library    please do not publish log-in info in a public web place  (also, log-in should not be needed while on campus, it should do it automatically)

And this FILE  is your cheat sheet to access and operations with EBSCO

Citation Style Guide from The American University in Washington D.C.

Large Stop Watch

Guidelines for Survey Design

George Mason University  guidelines on writing abstracts

Research guides from USC:

Academic Paper -  Abstract

Academic Paper - Introduction

Academic Paper -  Literature Review

Academic Paper -  Methodology

Academic Paper - Discussion

Research guides from DUC:

Real News, Fake News and Bad Arguments a Resource to identify them

Info-Graphics: Did I Plagiarize?  

Weekly Agendas and Resources

APR Grads Data for Feedback in 2022

Greetings AP Research Grads. It is now time to give back and nurture our next class, currently in AP Seminar.  I have created a calendar of openings and we need as many volunteers as possible in every slot. Please consider signing up to come to the AP Seminar classes to talk to the students about you project and offer your counsel and advice. We will all appreciate it very much. Add your name in the link here:

Weeks of May 3-14:

Notes for Finishing your Academic Paper

Week 31 April 19 - April 23  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 29: work sessions and POD zoom link: PODs begin

Draft  APR Presentation/Oral Defense Calendar 2021

POD  Scoring Rubric

Week 30 April 12 - April 16  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 29:  POD Prep and Peer Review

Week 29 March 22 - March 26  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 29:  POD prep work & POD selection process

Draft APR Presentation/Oral Defense Calendar 2021

RANDOM Number Generator

Week 28 March 22 - March 26  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 28:  Aca. Paper w/4000+ words & POD Slot selection

Academic Paper  Scoring Rubric

AP Research  Course & Exam Description

Week 27 March 15 - March 19  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 27: POD Rubric and Beginning of Presentation work

AP Research Course & Exam Description

Week 26  March 8 - March 12  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 26:  Academic Paper - 3000 words & PODs

Week 25  March 1 - March 5  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 25: Academic Paper and Plagiarism

Week 24  February 22 - February 26  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 24:  Planning and Work Sessions

Week 23  February 15 - February 19  Spring Break

Week 22  February 8 - February 12  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 21:  Data Analysis Part 4

Week 21  February 1 - February 5  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 21: Data Analysis Part 3

POD Scoring Rubric

Academic Paper Scoring Rubric

Data Visualization: The Gapminder

Week 20  January 25 - January 29  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 20:  Data Analysis Part 2  

Resource at Dominican University of California:

Real News, Fake News and Bad arguments:  Resources to identify them

  

Week 19  January 19 - January 22  Weekly Learning Plan

Slides for Week 19:  Cosntructing Arguments  

Resource to evaluate Media Bias at Ad Fontes Media Interactive Chart

Week 18  January 11 - January 15   Weekly Learning Plan  

Happy New Year and welcome back

Slides for Week 18: Work Flow, Aca Paper v4.0, and (peer Review)  

APR Key Calendar Events & Dates

Work on Data collection and increasing word count of Aca. Paper

Week 17  January 6 - January 8  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for Week 17: New Zoom info and re-entering your Project

==============================================

End of Semester 1

Week 16  December 14 - December 18  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for Week 16: Aca. Paper v3.0 & Final Exam S1

Work on Academic Paper v3.0

Final Exam - Semester end reflection

Week 15  December 7 - December 11  Weekly Learning Plan  

Roster of AP Research  Projects 2020-21    

Examples of Final Academic Papers from Redwood

AP Research Academic Paper Student 1

AP Research Academic Paper Student 2

AP Research Academic Paper Student 3

Week 14  November 30 - December 4  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation Week 14  : Abstracts & Academic Paper v3.0

Week 13  November 16 - 20  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for week 13 : Abstracts & Final IPF + IRB form + Consent Form for Approval

Roster of AP Research Projects 2020-21    

   

Week 12  November 9 - 13  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for week 12 : Survey Design, Introduction to Sampling, IPF Final

Resource for help  Designing Surveys  

More Examples of IPF

Student  5 Final IPF

Student  6 Final IPF  

Student  7 Final IPF  

Student 8  Final IPF

Final IPF Example  Student 4

Population Proportion Sample Size Calculator

Statistical Calculator for designing Clinical Research

Some Statistics Calculators  from Wolfram Alpha

Student #8 Academic Paper

Week 11  November 2 - 6  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for Week 11 :  Backwards planning for the semester and objectives for semester 1

Final IPF Example Student 4

Week 10  October 26 - 30  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for week 10 : IPF v2.0 and work sessions

Week 9  October 19 - 23  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for Presentation for week 9 : Validity, Reliability and Methodology

Week 8  October 12 - 16  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for week 8 : IPF, Ethics, and Consent

AP Research  IPF form in page 54  

Informed Consent Form:  ACTIVE CONSENT

Informed Consent Form:  PASSIVE CONSENT

TUHSD Request to consduct research:   TUHSD IRB FORM

IPF Example  Student 1  

IPF Example  Student 2

IPF Example  Student 3

AP Research Classwork Rubric  

Week 7  October 5 - 9  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for week 7 : Research Design and Methodologies

Week 6  September 28-October 2  Weekly Learning Plan  

Link to the  Agenda for the week

Slides for  Presentation for Week 6 :  First Elevator Speech

Week 5  September 21-25  Weekly Learning Plan  

Slides for  Presentation for Week 5 : Literature Review and Next Steps 

Week 4  September 14-18   Weekly Learning Plan . 

Slides for  Presentation for Week 4  : Backwards Planning and the Role of Theory in Research

Research Methods at Cambridge:  How to write a great research paper - 2012 Lecture 6 - Research Skills  

List of Research Methodologies

AP Research IPF form in page 54  

Week 3  September 7-11   Weekly Learning Plan . 

LibGuides: Finding the gap

Slides for Presentation for week 3 : Annotated Bibliography and Ethical Considerations

Seminal Papers list  by Discipline from Google Scholar

Week 2 August 24 - September 4    Weekly learning plan s 1 and  Link to the Agenda for the week

Days 1 and 2  Introductory Thoughts

Slides on Presentation for week 1 : What is Research?

Slides on Presentation for Week 2   W riting a Research Proposal:  What, Why, How

395 Doherty Drive

Larkspur, CA 94939

[email protected]

Office Hours

Monday-Friday

7:30-4:00 PM

Main 415.945.3600

Transcript Fax 415.945.3625

Attendance 415.945.3679

Tip Line 415.945.3693

Blackboard, Inc. All rights reserved.

IMAGES

  1. Examples Of College Capstone Papers

    ap capstone research paper example

  2. Ap Capstone Research Sample Papers

    ap capstone research paper example

  3. AP Capstone

    ap capstone research paper example

  4. Examples Of College Capstone Papers

    ap capstone research paper example

  5. AP Capstone Diploma

    ap capstone research paper example

  6. Pin by Iris Crankfield on AP Capstone

    ap capstone research paper example

VIDEO

  1. "Le Prêcheur Itinérant" chant special

  2. MY CAPSTONE SHIFT IN THE PICU

  3. WIL Experience ร่วมเปิดมุมมองการทำงานในสถานประกอบการจริงโดย ก้องภพ สุพร

  4. The Capstone Diploma Program

  5. 11.3.2022

  6. Introducing The TBS AP Capstone Program

COMMENTS

  1. AP Research Performance Task Sample and Scoring Information

    Download sample Academic Papers along with scoring guidelines and scoring distributions. If you are using assistive technology and need help accessing these

  2. AP Research

    AP Capstone is a trademark owned by College Board. ... AP® Research — Academic Paper 2021 Scoring Guidelines ... Word Count: 5303. Research Sample B 1 of 99

  3. Papers

    College Board Sample Paper A (2018). Cultivation, Resistance, & Beauty: A Case Study on the Defiant Gardens of the Manzanar Internment Camp during World War

  4. AP CAPSTONE

    Sample Peer Reviewed Paper - Another Good Generic Model. LINKS To AP Research Materials, Assignments, Deadlines ... Capstone Academic Research Paper.

  5. AP Research Academic Paper

    These studies collect a sample of entrepreneurs working in NGOs or DBL organizations and then group them based on their common traits. They then conduct

  6. AP Research Student Samples from the 2016 Exam: Academic Paper

    AP Research Performance Task Rubric: Academic Paper. Content. Area. Performance Levels. 1. Understand and Analyze. Context. The paper identifies the topic

  7. AP Research Handouts

    ap-capstone-digital-portfolio-student-user-guide · Rubric_Capstone-Research-Academic-Paper-2018_updated ... Socratic Seminar Sample Paper.

  8. AP RESEARCH

    AP Research Summer Work · Research Paper Rubric.pdf (2018-present). Course Proficiencies Rubric Outline.pdf (2017-present).

  9. AP Capstone / AP Research Home

    AP Research is open to students who have successfully completed AP Seminar in their Junior year. ... Examples of Final Academic Papers from Redwood.

  10. Trevor Packer on Twitter: "Another example of a good AP Research

    AP Capstone Research students achieved the highest-yet percentage of research papers earning scores of 3+, even as teachers expanded the course to more than