walmart case study germany

MBA Knowledge Base

Business • Management • Technology

Home » Management Case Studies » Case Study: Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany

Case Study: Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany

Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. is the largest retailer in the world, the world’s second-largest company and the nation’s largest non-governmental employer. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. operates retail stores in various retailing formats in all 50 states in the United States. The Company’s mass merchandising operations serve its customers primarily through the operation of three segments. The Wal-Mart Stores segment includes its discount stores, Supercenters, and Neighborhood Markets in the United States. The Sam’s club segment includes the warehouse membership clubs in the United States. The Company’s subsidiary, McLane Company, Inc. provides products and distribution services to retail industry and institutional foodservice customers. Wal-Mart serves customers and members more than 200 million times per week at more than 8,416 retail units under 53 different banners in 15 countries. With fiscal year 2010 sales of $405 billion, Wal-Mart employs more than 2.1 million associates worldwide. Nearly 75% of its stores are in the United States, but Wal-Mart is expanding internationally. The Group is engaged in the operations of retail stores located in all 50 states of the United States, Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Japan, Puerto Rico and the United Kingdom, Central America, Chile, Mexico,India and China.

Wal-Mart’s Entry and Operation in Germany

Wal-Mart’s initial entry into German market was through the acquisitions of renowned 21 store Wertkauf chain for an estimated $1.04 billion in December 1997.It was  followed one year later by the acquisition of In-terspar’s 74 hypermarkets from Spar Handels AG, the German unit of the French Intermarche Group , for ‚¬560 million. Thus Wal-Mart immediately became the country’s fourth biggest operator of hypermarkets. However, with a turnover of around ‚¬2.9 billion, and a stagnating market share of just 1.1 per cent, the US giant still was a negligible one in the German retail market. Even worse, with estimated accumulated losses of more than ‚¬ 1 billion, it is literally drowning in red ink although, according to Wal-Mart Germany’s CEO, Kay Hafner, its non food assortment, which accounts for around 50 per cent of its revenues, is profitable. Instead of expanding its network of stores by 50 units by early 2001, as originally planned, the company has been forced to close two big outlets, while at the same time it was only able to fully remodel three locations into its flagship Super center format. Due to its problems the company also had to lay off around 1.000 staff. On July 2006, Wal-Mart announced   its official defeat in Germany and  would sell its 85 German stores to the rival supermarket chain Metro and would book a pre-tax loss of about $1 billion ( £536 million) on the failed venture.

A Critical Analysis of Reasons for Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany

There were several factors that contributed to Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany. Amazing management blunders have plagued Wal-Mart’s German operation from the very start. Wal-Mart’s major mistakes on the German market may be summarized as follows.

• Cultural Insensitivity was the major reason of failure.
• Entry to German market by acquisition strategy.
• Failure to deliver on its legendary “every-day low prices” and “excellent service” value   proposition.
• Bad Publicity about the company due to breaking of some prevailing German law and regulations.

In January 1997, Wal-Mart had first entry in Europe market with the acquisition of Wertkauf hypermarkets in Germany.   Later in that year, Wal-Mart also acquired Interspar, another German hypermarket chain. While its first move — the 1997 takeover of the 21 Wertkaufstores  was indeed a shrewd one, given that company’s excellent earnings, its competitive locations, and its very capable management. Wal-Mart’s 1998 follow-updeal with Spar for 74 hypermarkets was widely judged an ill-informed, ill-advised act, for several reasons. Spar is considered to be the weakest player on the German market due to its mostly run-down stores, very heterogeneous in size and format, with the majority of them located in less well-off inner-city residential areas.

Wal-Mart’s cultural insensitivity led to its failure in Germany.

Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany – A Case of Cultural Insensitivity

Most of the Global mergers and acquisitions failed to produce any benefit for the shareholders or reduced value, which was mainly due to the lack of intercultural competence. Lack of sensitivity and understanding of language barriers, local traditions, consumer behavior, merchandising, and employment practices irreversibly damaged Wal-Mart’s image in Germany. One of the main reasons that failed Wal-Mart in Germany is when it attempted to transport the company’s unique culture and retailing concept to the new country. The top management refused to even acknowledge the differences in customer behavior and culture in Germany when compared to its US customers, and the top management failed to listen to the feedback from its employees. Not every new cross- border retailer can be a retail giant outer its home.   The mistake of exporting its culture wholesale, rather than adapting to local market, leads Wal-Mart failed in Germany market.

Wal-Mart’s ambitions to position itself profitably in European markets through Germany have been hit badly by their inability to fully understand and to adapt to the specific conditions of doing business in other countries. This exposed their obvious lack of intercultural competence and management skills. The main challenge of post-merger integration is further complicated significantly if it is in a Cross-border Merger or acquisition, with all issues frequently being compounded by a lack of language and culture bridging skills. Failure to accomplish this task satisfactorily, results in mutual distrust, de-motivation and negatively impacts the merged companies’ competitiveness, profits and shareholder value. This is exactly what happened to Wal-Mart Germany.

Following are the main two factors that contributed to the  Wal-Mart’s Failure in Germany;

1) Specific Difference in German Consumer behavior and Culture in comparison with US consumers:

The biggest mistake of Wal-Mart was to ignore the local culture, local buying habits and impose an American boss on its German operations. Wal-Mart stores are designed for customers who are willing to spend lot of time shopping. But in Germany, the shopping hours are shorter: Shops close by 5 PM on weekdays, and no shopping on Sundays. This meant that customers don’t have the habit of spending lots of time in a store – wandering around for the things they need. Coupled with this problem, German customers do not like to be assisted by Wal-Mart’s friendly store assistants. Germans prefer to do their own search for bargains. Instead of understanding and adjusting to the culture of its clients, Wal-Mart tried to impose their Culture on to the Customers, which never worked out.

Germans like to see the advertised discount products upfront without having to ask the store assistant. This implies that the discount products must be placed at the eye level. Instead Wal-Mart chose to use its US style merchandise display strategy – where premium priced products are kept at eye level and discount products are kept at higher shelf or in the bottom racks. This irritated the German shoppers. Wal-Mart also got its store inventory wrong, Wal-Mart stocked its store with clothes, hardware, electronics and other non-food products were given much bigger floor space than food products, as a result more than 50% of the revenue was from non-food products. But other German retailers stock more of food products. For example for Metro, food products constitute more than 75% of the revenue. Germans prefer to bag groceries themselves into reusable carriers, or at least to pay a small fee for the avoidable sin of needing a plastic bag.

German’s are introvert in nature and doesn’t like display of emotion in public, as they always care for their private personal space. Employees, like the reserved customers, didn’t care for Wal-Mart’s public displays of corporate moral such as the morning cheer. The German Customer’s even didn’t liked to be accompanied by the Cheerful employees either, as they would like to make choices by themselves. These are cultural misunderstandings as well, but one could say the cultural philosophy of Wal-Mart could not survive in the context of a German culture with a Happy Planet Index significantly higher than America’s.

2) Inefficient Top Management which ignored the relevance of local Culture:

It was clear that the cultural insensitivity of Wal-Mart started right at the top management. To begin with, it appointed four CEOs during its first four years of operation. The first head of German operations was Rob Tiarks, an expat from the USA – who did not understand Germany or its culture. He had previously supervised around 200 Supercenters in America. Not only did he not speak any German. Due to his unwillingness to learn the language, English was soon decreed as the official company language at the management level. He also ignores the complexities and the legal framework of the German retail market, ignoring any strategic advice presented to him by former Wertkauf executives. This has resulted in the resignation of top three management executives from Wertkauf. His successors were also unsuccessful in integrating German Outlets with the Wal-Mart’s Business model and culture.

Other Reasons of Failure

A number of factors that resulted Wal-Mart’s failure in Germany are such as different corporate culture, political influence, stiff competition and inefficient management and marketing strategies . Firstly, David Wild, Wal-Mart’s CEO in 2004, believed that cultural differences between American and German consumers were considerable challenges to Wal-Mart. Debby, CEO in 2006, concluded that German shoppers are accustomed to shop at small scale discount stores such as Aldi and Netto that provides a limited range of products with special offers each week and no customer service, unlike US customers. In addition to different corporate culture, the competition has become gradually more intense between Wal-Mart and domestic retailers. The price difference has so lessened that sometimes even Wal-Mart had a higher price than their competitors. Consequently, consumers had little incentive to visit Wal-Mart Germany because of no obvious price advantage.

Some other factors that lead to Wal-Mart’s failure in Germany were, their strategy of acquiring the top competitor did not work, as the German government did its best to ensure the welfare of the domestic players. Also, due to wage restrictions, Wal-Mart could not practice wage bargaining, as it did back in U.S, this was a huge, uncommon expenditure for the company. Its American strategy of restricting employee freedom and forcing them to work extra hours, brought up problems of high labour turnover and a negative image as an employer. Wal-Mart failed to have an effective management at the top level. It’s CEO’s changed every year, this in an obvious way effected the company’s performance. Wal-Mart constantly ignored the strictness of German laws, and was charged heavy penalties for doing so. One of the most challenging thing for Wal-Mart was capturing the market- share. As per German legislation it was illegal to sell products below cost,because of which Wal-Mart could never achieve the ‘Low price leader’ tag.

It is impossible to smoothly run any organization, until there is co-operation between the employees and the employer. Wal-Mart faced a severe labour unrest,which hampered its brand-image. Kay Hafner,CEO of Wal-Mart reduced the wages to cut cost, this negatively influenced individual behaviour , as an anti-union decision. As suggested by Arndt and Knorr, a firm needs to understand the specifications when indulging in global expansion.Out of all the CEO’s, only David Wild has been sensitive to cultural difference.He did bring about changes based on this understanding,which had some positive results,yet not profitable enough to impress investors for future investments.

Moreover,as per German legislation their were some specific retail related laws, such as, limited legal working hours (80 hours/week) which were way less than the other European countries and had strict rules governing closure on Sunday’s and holidays. Wal-Mart repeatedly infringement German laws but were able to do away with it mainly because of global presence and influence on the government of US which played a major role in global politics. Some of incidences where the company broke few laws and was able to get away are summed up below:

• ‘Unfair trade’ practices such as selling goods below the cost price was prohibited in Germany but Wal-Mart was found violating these laws as it randomly sold some product below cost.
• German law required a company to disclose it financial statements annually, Wal-Mart seldom did that and was spared without any fine or legal proceedings at number of occasions.
• Obligatory Deposit Regulation’s law stipulated the retailer to provide deposit-refund-system on few products like metal beverages, cans etc. But Wal-Mart never followed this law.

Thus from the above incidences it can be concluded that Wal-Mart used its global influence to refrain from some of the German laws.

However, because German culture is quite different from American culture and because of unfamiliarity with the legislation, it would be difficult for Wal-Mart to make marketing and promotion right. And in fact these difficulties had been proved in Wal-Mart Germany. Consequently, rather than choosing Germany as the gateway to Europe, virtually after two years of operating in Germany it had entered in U.K. Even though U.K is not in the Euro zone and its geographic location is less favorable than Germany, it has a similar culture and legal environment as U.S. which makes it easier to operate the company’s business and strategies. It has considerable success in the UK market which is called by as a ‘Wal-Mart-ready’ market. Therefore, the lessons learned from from Wal-Mart’s failure in Germany has proven useful for U.K.

Suggestions and Recommendations

Cross-border, Cross-cultural business is a challenge even for the biggest companies. Companies have to be sensitive to the local cultures and tailor their offerings to local market. To localize their offerings, Wal-Mart and other Companies that are going global companies must carry out cultural assessment of the Citizens of the Country before acquisitions. All their Corporate Business and Communication strategies should be based on this cultural assessment. This will help companies measure the effectiveness of its localization efforts and make adequate changes in local strategy & tactics as and when required. Considering the following steps would help Wal-Mart or any other Company while they are on lookout of Global alliance or business.

1. Political, Social, Economic and Cultural Analysis of the Country

Before expanding its business operations to a new country, the Company should understand the Political, Social, Economic and cultural aspects of the Country in depth. Wal-Mart’s case, Germany was selected primarily because of a central European location and economic attractiveness of the Wertkauf acquisition. But a serious research would have shown that Germany had strong national values resistant to change ; possibly the most deeply rooted retail traditions in Western Europe. This could have avoided either Wal-Mart’s selection of the Country or the strategies it has adopted in Germany.

2. Go global and think they are local

After conducting an in depth research about the prevailing trends in the customer’s Country, the Company should be ready to modify its own identity to suit itself to the cultural differences without compromising much on its Corporate Mission . This step will also force organizations to clearly define globalization goals. Wal-Mart put the company name on many German stores before being fully established. Immediately, the run down stores left an impression on consumers who formed a negative image of the Wal-Mart name.

3. Employment of Cross-Cultural Management approaches

Employment of Hofsted’s Culture Dimensions or HT&T Analysis will help Companies in understanding the minute cultural differences between the countries. For example , Communitarianism over Individualism

Germans degree of communitarianism is on the higher side mainly because Germans prefer participating on a team. Most Germans see business as a group of related persons working together. But, most of Americans see their company as a set of functions, tasks, people, machines and payments in which individuals compete.

This difference in Cultural dimensions between the 2 countries has resulted in inside management conflict among the employees, which also resulted in resignation of efficient German executives from Wal-Mart post integration.

Understanding the cultural dimensions of a Country through proven Cross-Culture models will always help a company to formulate a specific approach that will encourage team spirit and joy among the Global Team.

4. Continuous Updation of Strategies to successfully withstand the local competition

It is very important for a Global firm to continuously analyse the impact of their various strategies on the local market. Understand the shortfalls, and modify it in such a way as to cater the local market in a much better way than the competitors. It is always better to scrutinize the strategies adopted by them with a panel of local experts, as they will be having a better picture about the local consuming behavior and culture. Perceptions do matter a lot, So a surveys to find the customer’s perception about the company will also help them to change their strategies accordingly.

Related Posts:

• Case Study: Supply Chain Management of Walmart
• Case Study of Walmart: Procurement and Distribution
• Case Study: How Walmart Enhances Supply Chain Management with ERP Initiatives?
• Case Study: McDonald's Business Strategies in India
• Case Study of Zara: Use of Technology to Improve Operational Responsiveness
• Case Study: Why Walmart Failed in Germany?
• Case Study: Wal-Mart's Distribution and Logistics System
• Case Study of McDonalds: Advertising and Promotion Strategies
• Case Study: Wal-Marts Competitive Advantage
• Case Study: Success of Starbucks Mobile Payment Application

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

9 Reasons Why Walmart Failed in Germany (Full Guide)

Walmart‘s attempt to expand into Germany from 1997 to 2006 stands as one of the company‘s biggest international failures. This retail giant found itself struggling to gain a foothold in the large German market. Walmart was forced to fully withdraw from Germany in 2006 after accumulating over $1 billion in losses.

So why couldn‘t this retail juggernaut find success in Germany? Let‘s closely examine the 9 major factors that led to Walmart‘s failure in Germany:

• Legal restrictions on undercutting competitor prices
• Clash with German labor laws and trade unions
• Underestimating entrenched local retail chains
• Overall struggles in the mature German retail sector
• Rejection of Walmart‘s corporate culture by employees
• Failure to understand German shopping habits
• Lack of focus in Walmart‘s broad product offerings
• Refusal to adapt the business model to the German economy
• Insufficient research prior to entry into the German market

By exploring each of these reasons in depth, we can gain insight into why Walmart was unable to replicate its American success on German soil. Understanding Walmart‘s German challenges also provides valuable lessons for international retailers seeking to expand into new markets.

Overview of German Retail Landscape Prior to Walmart‘s Arrival

Before diving into the specifics of why Walmart failed, it is helpful to understand the German retail landscape leading up to Walmart‘s market entry in 1997. This provides useful context for many of the challenges Walmart later faced.

Germany had a well-established retail industry dominated by small- to mid-size local and regional chains. The country‘s retail scene was characterized by the spread of discount grocers like Aldi and Lidl, which had captured the loyalty of German consumers seeking value. Germany also had a number of mid-size chains like Spar, Edeka, and Reewe serving various retail segments.

Unlike the American retail landscape filled with massive national big-box retailers, even the largest German chains had only captured single digit market share. Retail consolidation was happening at a much slower pace compared to the rapid rise of national chains in the US.

The German grocery sector in particular was known for being a challenging market with razor thin margins. Growth was slow across the entire German retail industry leading up to Walmart‘s arrival, averaging just 0.3% annual growth between 1996 and 2001.

With mature retailers entrenched across the country, limited prime retail locations, and discount chains capitalizing on the value-focused German shopper, the competitve conditions were far from ideal for a foreign newcomer like Walmart.

Reason 1: Legal Restrictions on Price Undercutting

Walmart built its American retail empire on aggressively low prices enabled by an efficient supply chain and economies of scale. A key part of Walmart‘s playbook has been undercutting competitors‘ prices to rapidly steal market share upon entry into new markets.

However, in Germany, Walmart‘s strategy of pricing below competitors ran afoul of strict German regulations. Germany prohibits companies from engaging in predatory pricing or selling goods below cost in order to protect small businesses from unfair competition.

In 2004, after years of complaints from German retailers, Germany‘s Federal Cartel Office ordered Walmart to raise its prices after proving the retailer was violating these laws. This legal restriction prevented Walmart from using its pricing advantage to achieve the same rapid success it enjoyed in the United States and other international markets.

Jürgen Weber, president of Germany’s Federal Cartel Office in 2004, stated Walmart’s obsession with low prices “was hurting retailers in Germany.” This dealt a major blow to Walmart’s core retail strategy.

Reason 2: Clash With German Labor Laws and Trade Unions

Walmart also encountered major obstacles trying to replicate its labor model in Germany. The company adamantly opposed German labor laws and clashes with trade unions created severe public relations challenges.

In the US, Walmart has taken a staunch anti-union stance, even closing down stores that voted to unionize. Walmart also pays low wages without benefits which enables its discount pricing.

Attempting to import this labor model into Germany brought Walmart into direct conflict with the country‘s strong labor laws and retail sector trade unions. German retail employees represented by unions were accustomed to higher wages due to collective bargaining.

When Walmart refused to join collective wage negotiations, the workers‘ unions staged protests and strikes in 2000 to demand higher pay. This conflict resonated strongly in labor-friendly Germany and gave Walmart a reputation for mistreating workers.

In 2006, Walmart again faced union protests over plans to cut hundreds of jobs and slash wages by over 25% for some workers after taking over a German retail chain.

Walmart failed to realize the political strength of German retail unions and importance of collective wage negotiations. Their resistance to adhering to local labor laws created backlash that hurt market share and amplified the challenges they already faced competing with established German chains.

Reason 3: Underestimating the Power of Established Local Retailers

Industry experts noted that Walmart failed to recognize how difficult it would be to compete with smaller German discount grocers like Aldi and Lidl. While Walmart anticipated big success based on its size and scale, the market realities in Germany differed greatly.

Aldi and Lidl had fine tuned efficient lean operations that allowed them to remain price competitive with Walmart, despite Walmart‘s greater size. These discount chains had cultivated decades of brand loyalty among German consumers seeking reliable value.

Local retailers knew the regional German markets intricately which gave them advantages in managing supply chains and store locations compared to Walmart‘s US-style operations.

Walmart incorrectly assumed that German shoppers would flock to its stores based on the reputation of its American success. But German shoppers remained loyal to their local discount brands, which had national market share of 40% combined by the mid-2000s.

Deep Dive into German Shopping Habits and Values

To fully understand the competitive challenges Walmart faced, it is essential to highlight key differences between American and German shopping habits and cultural values.

Surveys showed German customers cared more about consistent quality and brand loyalty over getting the absolute lowest price. As one retail analyst described it: "Germans will rarely go more than 100 meters out of their way to save 5% on their groceries."

Additionally, German shoppers preferred small, specialized local stores they could walk to rather than driving to distant retail warehouses offering one-stop shopping convenience. Environmental consciousness was also stronger among German consumers.

Beyond shopping habits, Walmart‘s overly friendly and enthusiastic American corporate culture clashed with German cultural norms. Service with a constant smile was seen as strange compared to the more muted service style in German stores.

Mandatory morning stretches and company chants failed to resonate with German employees who preferred a clear separation between their personal and work lives.

This extended to dating policies which restricted employees from having romantic relationships. While common in the US, in Germany this was seen as an intrusion into workers‘ privacy rather than an acceptable corporate guideline.

In these areas, Walmart misjudged the market by relying on false assumptions from its American success that German shoppers would prioritize ultra-low prices over factors like quality, brand relationships and corporate values.

Profile of Major German Retail Competitors

To highlight the competitive challenges Walmart faced in Germany, it is worth profiling a few of the major incumbent players that fought to maintain market share against the American retail giant:

Aldi – With roots dating back to 1913, Aldi had established itself as the dominant discount grocery chain in Germany with over 2,200 stores by the 1990s. Aldi had mastered no-frills efficiency which enabled it to compete aggressively on price against larger new entrants. Its brand reputation for value kept German shoppers loyal even when big retailers tried to undercut prices.

Edeka – As the largest supermarket corporation in Germany, Edeka posed a formidable competitor to Walmart in the grocery segment. With over 13,000 stores under a cooperative model, Edeka already had scale and substantial buying power on par with Walmart. Edeka focused on high quality produce and goods to differentiate itself.

KarstadtQuelle – This department store and mail order company was created via a merger in 1999, forming one of Germany‘s largest diversified retailers. Its department store channel generated over $15 billion in sales, creating a massive incumbent retailer for Walmart to try to compete against.

These established retail giants, along with other strong local and regional chains, made the German market inhospitable for Walmart from the start.

Reason 4: Germany‘s Mature and Stagnant Retail Sector

As highlighted earlier, beyond the challenges of local competitors, Walmart entered Germany during a period of stagnation for the entire retail sector.

From 1996 to 2001, food retail chains in Germany were only growing revenues by 0.3% per year on average. Non-food retail was similarly stagnant with minimal growth annually over that period.

Germany‘s dense population and developed economy meant that opportunities for retail expansion were far more limited compared to growing international markets. For example, Walmart saw 14.5% annual sales growth when it entered China in 1996 compared to the 0.3% sluggishness in German retail.

The mature nature of German retail meant a tortoise-like battle for each percentage point of market share rather than rapid growth potential. Facing this reality, the viability of achieving a reasonable return on Walmart‘s investments in Germany was dubious from the outset.

Reason 5: Rejection of Walmart‘s Corporate Culture

As highlighted earlier when contrasting American and German cultural values, significant aspects of Walmart‘s corporate culture failed to resonate in Germany.

From requiring hourly cheers to banning relationships between coworkers, Walmart‘s attempts to impose its own values were rejected by German employees. Worker morale and productivity at Walmart locations suffered as a result.

German workers were accustomed to a separation between professional and private lives. Walmart‘s corporate culture blurred this line substantially compared to German retail norms.

For example, when a female Walmart employee was demoted due to a relationship with a lower level male employee, she sued the company in Germany. Courts ruled in her favor, stating that Walmart had violated German constitutional rights to make personal life choices. This exemplified Walmart‘s friction with German cultural values.

Reason 6: Failure to Understand German Shopping Habits

Earlier we touched on a few aspects of how German shopper motivations differed from the American consumers Walmart built its business around. Here are some additional statistics that highlight key habit differences:

91% of Germans lived within a 10 minute walk of the nearest grocer, compared to 36% of Americans, making convenience less important.

The number one factor for Germans choosing a grocery store was quality of products (43%), followed by proximity (29%), then price (18%).

Germans made grocery trips 3.5 times per week on average compared to 1.5 times for Americans, with smaller daily purchases.

Car ownership rates were lower in Germany‘s urban areas. Walking and public transport were more common.

The average size of a German grocery store was 5,000 square feet whereas Walmart stores averaged 180,000 square feet.

Walmart attempted to replicate its American big-box suburbs and convenience-focused shopping experience despite clear data showing significant differences in how Germans shopped.

Reason 7: Unfocused Retail Strategy in Germany

Rather than home in on a particular segment where it may have stood a chance, Walmart attempted a broad retail expansion in Germany across grocery, general merchandise, restaurants, and clothing.

Critics pointed out Walmart may have fared better by acquiring a single discount chain and focusing on improving operations in that one brand.

But Walmart‘s ambitions were far grander, envisioning replacing Germany‘s many leading retailers with one new national big box chain. This strategy clearly did not resonate with German shoppers who were familiar and comfortable shopping at their existing local specialty businesses.

With so many different retail categories to compete in with entrenched incumbents, Walmart spread itself too thin in Germany and lacked focus.

Reason 8: Refusal to Adapt to the German Retail Ecosystem

At its core, Walmart failed in Germany because the company was unwilling to adapt in fundamental ways to accommodate significant differences from its successful US model.

As we‘ve explored, there were major contrasts between America and Germany in regulations, labor laws, incumbent competitors, and shopping culture. Rather than acknowledge these barriers, Walmart rigidly clung to what had worked well in America.

From corporate structures to supply chains to pricing, Walmart made half-hearted German concessions only when forced. In the eyes of German shoppers and employees, Walmart refused to become a genuine German company.

As one retail consultant noted: “You can’t just transplant a foreign system into a country and not adapt it to local conditions." Walmart took the opposite approach.

Reason 9: Lack of Research Prior to Entry

Many industry experts noted that Walmart did not do its homework prior to entering Germany. Its misguided strategy indicates a lack of research into German regulations, competitors, and shopper preferences.

Had Walmart invested time studying German retail and cultural norms, some of the brewing challenges would have become apparent before sinking billions into its doomed expansion.

Instead, Walmart relied on assumptions of easy market domination due to its scale and clout. But major international expansions require due diligence to understand subtle but crucial differences in local markets.

Rather than data-driven strategic planning, Walmart‘s confidence led to blindness that made failure in Germany nearly inevitable.

Conclusion and Lessons Learned

Walmart‘s failure in Germany stands as a classic business school case study in how cultural arrogance can blind a successful company from seeing dangers in a new market.

Walmart failed to deeply research the German retail landscape, regulations, and culture. They projected false assumptions based on their American model rather than gathering data. When problems surfaced, Walmart remained inflexible instead of adapting.

For international retailers, Walmart‘s German cautionary tale reinforces the need to think globally but act locally. What works in one market may fail in another. Companies must be willing to adapt practices, policies, and even corporate values to accommodate local conditions and differences.

Without flexibility and humility, international expansion attempts can suffer the same costly fate Walmart endured in Germany.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 6

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Share this:

You may like to read,.

• Does Walmart Sell Lottery Tickets in 2022? Yes, Here‘s Your Complete Guide to Buying Lottery Tickets at Walmart
• Does Walmart Have Layaway in 2022? Your Complete Guide to Holiday Layaway
• Got Headphones You Need To Return? Here‘s Walmart‘s 2023 Policy
• Why Steelyard Walmart is Considered the Worst Walmart in America for 2024
• Does Walmart Sell Victoria’s Secret Gift Cards In 2023?
• How Does Walmart Track Shoplifting In 2024? (Warning)
• Does Walmart Use TeleCheck and Certegy to Verify Checks in 2024?
• Is Dollar General Owned By Walmart In 2022?

Search form

You are here.

• Case, example of product failure: Wal-Mart in Germany, 1997 to 2006

Wal-Mart is the biggest food retailer in the world and has a presence in several nations. In some nations (e.g. the US, Canada, China), Wal-Mart is a great success. However, Wal-Mart has failed in some countries (e.g. Germany, South Korea). First, we describe Wal-Mart’s failure in Europe’s largest economy. Second, we use Wal-Mart’s experiences in Germany to illustrate some key principles related to product failure and product deletion (see Table 13.4 ). Wal-Mart’s experiences are also an example of the importance to adapt to culture when starting a business in a new country.

The German grocery industry

There is fierce competition in the German grocery industry, due to the increasing number of discount supermarket chains (KPMG 2006). As a result, there is low profitability in the food retail sector; profit margins range from 0.5 per cent to 1 per cent which is one of the lowest profit margins in Europe (Frankfurter Rundschau 2007). By contrast, profit margins in Great Britain are 5 per cent, in this same sector. In particular, Metro is a tough competitor, and it already applies some of Wal-Mart’s successful strategies (e.g. related to economics of scale and low prices). Of course, Wal-Mart is interested in other metrics beyond profit (e.g. shareholder wealth, market share), but, as indicated above, profitability and margins are of key concern to retailers.

Wal-Mart: strategic concept

Wal-Mart is the world’s largest retailer with approximately 6,500 stores worldwide (Business 2006). The main feature of Wal-Mart’s business model is to cut costs (continuously) and therefore offer lower prices than their competitors. For instance, Wal-Mart has introduced new logistical technologies such as radio-frequency identification (RFID) to optimize its logistic processes. RFID is an automatic identification method, relying on storing and remotely retrieving data using devices called RFID tags or transponders. Wal-Mart tries to minimize labor costs by offering minimal health care plans. Wal-Mart pressures its suppliers to cut costs, on a continuous basis. In brief, Wal-Mart’s managers are constantly seeking out ways to cut costs, and some of their successes are passed on to shoppers, in terms of lower prices.

Wal-Mart’s entry into the german market

In 1997, Wal-Mart acquired over 21 stores from the supermarket chain “Wertkauf.” One year later, Wal-Mart bought an additional 74 stores from the supermarket chain “Interspar”. As a result, Wal-Mart became the fourth biggest operator of supermarkets in Germany (Lebensmittelzeitung 2006). The objective was to expand to 500 stores in Germany. However, the number of stores never exceeded the 95 stores that were originally purchased in the first two years. Wal-Mart’s position in the marketplace deteriorated over the years. In 2002, Wal-Mart had some financial difficulties due to a low turnover which resulted in the dismissal of some employees. At the end of 2006, Wal-Mart was bought out by “Metro”, one of Germany’s largest retail groups. Finally, Wal-Mart left the German market with a loss of one billion dollars before tax (Manager-Magazin 2006).

Mis-steps in the german market

In general, there are five key issues related to Wal-Mart’s ultimate withdrawal from Germany: ( a) market structure; (b) business model (these first two are discussed together here); c) cultural and communication; (d) politics and regulation; and (e) product/service failure. Each of these issues is discussed in turn. Note also that these five issues are highlighted in Table 13.4 .

Market structure and business model

A retailer that wants to follow Wal-Mart’s strategy of low prices needs to expand rapidly. In Germany, there not enough appropriate locations to support such expansion (see Table 13.4 ). As previously mentioned, Wal-Mart did not build their own stores but took over 21 existing “Wertkauf” supermarkets that had a totally different business model. The stores themselves were very small and had a limited range of goods. A related problem is that these stores were located far apart, which resulted in high logistical costs.

When entering a new market, it is important to anticipate competitors’ reactions. In Germany, Wal-Mart’s biggest competitor, Metro, wanted to expand their stores; at the same time, Metro wanted to prevent Wal-Mart from executing their expansion plans (Senge 2004). Many times, a product has to be deleted because the competition is too strong.

With the strategy of “Every day low prices,” Wal-Mart is very successful in the United States and also in many other countries. In Germany, there is extreme competition in the retail food sector. Therefore, the German customer is quite accustomed to the low prices that are offered by numerous discount supermarket chains. For this reason, Wal-Mart’s strategy of offering low prices did not create sufficient competitive advantage (see Table 13.4 ).

Culture and communication

When products are introduced, it is important to consider cultural factors. In this case, corporate culture played a key role. Wal-Mart’s top executives decided to operate the German locations from their offices in the United Kingdom. Thus, Wal-Mart’s “corporate language” was English. However, many of the older Wal-Mart managers in Germany do not speak English. As a result, there were often breakdowns in communication. Some managers of the acquired stores did not stay on after the Wal-Mart acquisition. Key business connections were lost. As a result, several key suppliers (e.g. Adidas, Samsonite, Nike) declined to work as suppliers for Wal-Mart. Wal-Mart did not just lose important suppliers; they also lost an important part of their range of goods (Senge 2004). The situation could have been improved by retaining and communicating effectively with the German managers who had know-how about the local market (see Table 13.4 ).

Politics and regulation

The managers of Wal-Mart were not sufficiently familiar with the laws and regulations in Germany, as they violated them several times. One of Wal-Mart’s fundamental principles is to stay union free. However, in Germany, unions have a powerful position. Through collective bargaining and related tactics, they can have a strong influence on political decision making. Ver.di is a German union in the service sector. With 2.4 million members, it is one of the largest independent, trade unions in the world (Ver.di 2008).

According to the German Commercial Code, all incorporated companies are obligated to publish a financial statement, including a profit and loss statement. Due to the fact that Wal-Mart refused to publish their financial statements for the years 1999 and 2000, Ver.di sued in a court of law. Wal-Mart was sentenced to pay a fine. The coverage of this law suit in the German press led to a negative public image for Wal-Mart.

After the expansion strategy failed due to the lack of suitable store locations, Wal-Mart began a price war to drive small competitors out of business. The intention was to take over the stores of the insolvent supermarket chains and convert them into Wal-Mart stores. One part of the price war was to introduce a private label called “Smart Brand” and sell most of these products below manufacturing costs. The reaction of many competitors was to decrease their prices, which led to a profit setback for the entire industry. However, the Federal Cartel Office interceded and stopped the price war because there is a law in Germany that enjoins companies from selling goods below manufacturing costs on a continuing basis (Knorr and Arndt 2003).

Product/ service failure

Wal-Mart planned to introduce a sophisticated customer service program which threatened many of its competitors because German discount supermarket chains often do not provide good customer service. Therefore, good customer service, combined with low prices, could have been a new market niche in Germany. One part of Wal-Mart’s customer service program was called the “ten foot rule”. Every ten feet, a service employee offered some help to the customer (Knorr and Arndt 2003). However, the customer reaction was rather negative, because customers who normally do their grocery shopping in discount supermarket chains are used to self-service. They do not necessarily expect to talk with employees.

Therefore, the “ten foot rule” was perceived as rather annoying and did not result in a reputation for providing good customer service.

Wal-Mart also imported the idea of placing a “greeter” at the entrance to the store. Again, German customers were not used to this custom, and they did not adopt this “service” with any enthusiasm.

Conclusion of Wal-Mart Mini-case

Wal-Mart tried to apply its US success formula in an unmodified manner to the German market. As a result, they didn’t have sufficient knowledge about the market structure and key cultural / political issues. In addition, structural factors prevented Wal-Mart from fully implementing its successful business model. Also, there were some instances of product or service failure. The final outcome was that Wal-Mart had to abandon its offerings in Germany.

• 43240 reads
• Are entrepreneurs born or made? “The Mindset of an Entrepreneur”
• When to plant your market opportunity seeds “Stop and Go Signs for Accessing Market Opportunity Matrix”
• What will I sell?
• Places for inspiration
• Financing: the fundamental rim on the wheel
• Strategy: the tactical rim on the wheel
• Branding coaching What is the brand advantage?
• The Brand Identity Guide: A blueprint toward success
• The stems of growing startups: definitions of “startup stakeholder arrow” selected terms
• Making good: elements of a values-based company culture
• Going green on a shoe string
• Water your plants: operations hydrate your startup
• A new product bud is blooming: introducing the “New Venture Instructional Manual to Operational Excellence” “New Venture Instructional Manual to Operational Excellence”
• Let the fruits of your labor blossom: the new product/service launch event plan “Checklist for a New Product Launch Event
• The public relations practitioner’s tool kit
• Mentor insights: the “Where the Rubber Meets the Road” spokes on the wheel Jay Milbrandt’s Journal Entries from Bangladesh - Not Just Statistics Jay Milbrandt’s Journal Entries from Bangladesh - Why I Have Hope Jay Milbrandt’s Journal Entries from Bangladesh - Moving the Mountains of Poverty Jay Milbrandt’s Journal Entries from Bangladesh - What Third World?
• About this author and acknowledgements
• Entrepreneurial mindset enhancing activities
• Chapter summary
• Examples of successful business models
• Model implementation/testing pre-requisites
• Real expectations outcome: benefits
• Success factors
• Conclusions
• The product model vs the marketing model
• The marketing model
• Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
• Identifying customer’s wants successfully
• Models of industry attractiveness; the strategic perspective
• The BCG matrix
• The McKinsey matrix
• Downes’ three new forces
• Market research to determine the potential market for funeral services in Monterrey, Mexico
• Discussion questions
• Introduction
• Organizational issues
• Organizational stages of growth
• Departmentation by function
• Departmentation by products
• Departmentation by projects
• Departmentation by matrix
• Flat organizations
• Tall organizations
• Centralized
• Decentralized
• Chapter summary Us legal issues
• Competitive advantage through human resource management
• Providing employee voice and influence
• Managing differences in organizations
• Methods of recruitment
• Evaluating recruiting policies
• Selective hiring
• Behavioral interview
• Situational interview
• Selection tests
• Background checks
• Benefits of training
• Need for training
• Training methods
• Training in the context of global business
• Aligning employee career development with organizational growth Best of East and West
• Purpose of appraisals
• Creating an appropriate appraisal process
• Appraisal methods
• Performing the appraisal
• Giving feedback
• Receiving feedback
• Internal equity
• External equity
• Combining internal and external equity
• The benefit of benefits
• Detriments of benefits
• Compensation techniques
• Components of pay for performance
• Pay secrecy
• Good outcomes of paying for performance
• Folly of reward systems in different organizations
• Cautions for introducing a pay system
• Elements to job design
• Brief history of traditional approaches to job design
• Current approaches to job design
• Steps to effective job design
• How meaningful job design can impact an organization
• Defining marketing
• Macromarketing versus micromarketing
• Service marketing versus goods marketing
• For-profit marketing versus nonprofit marketing
• Mass marketing, direct marketing, and Internet marketing
• Local, regional, national, international, and global marketers
• Consumer goods marketing and business-to-business (industrial) marketing
• Standardization and customization
• Reasons for entering international markets
• Reasons to avoid international markets
• The stages of going international
• Joint ventures
• Direct investment
• US commercial centers
• Trade intermediaries
• The corporate level
• The business level
• Marketing objectives
• The functional level
• Product/promotion
• Distribution and logistics
• Evaluating results
• Business norms
• Religious beliefs
• Political stability
• Monetary circumstances
• Trading blocs and agreements
• Expropriation
• The technological environment
• The economic environment
• The competitive environment
• One of three strategic functions
• Strategic versus tactical operations decisions
• Operations management provides competitive advantage!
• The input/output transformation model
• Inventory decisions
• Capacity decisions
• Quality decisions
• Scheduling decisions
• Process decisions
• Technology decisions
• Location decisions
• Quality costs
• TQM’s seven basic elements
• Quality awards and standards
• Causes of the bullwhip effect
• Counteracting the bullwhip effect
• Other factors affecting supply chain management
• Supplier selection
• Inventory reduction to expose waste
• Demand-pull production system
• Quick setups to reduce lot sizes
• Uniform plant loading
• Flexible resources
• Line/cellular flow layouts
• Total Quality Management
• Employee empowerment
• Conclusion: The evolution of JIT into “lean operations”
• Trends in management
• Trust: the foundation for a successful relationship
• Functional relationship
• Relational partnership
• Strategic partnership
• Foundations of successful relationships
• Phases of relationship development
• Skills for building positive relationships
• Outsourcing
• Potential external relationship obstacles
• Why an accounting system is important
• Basic types of accounts
• Chart of accounts
• Basic financial statements
• A short history of accounting and double entry bookkeeping
• Types of ledgers
• Cash flow forecasts
• Working capital analyses
• Profitability analyses (e.g. by customer, product, region)
• Sources of financing for your organization
• The technology sub-system
• The process sub-system
• Relationships between the four components
• Some practical advice for start-ups
• Acquiring a suite of commonly-used programs
• When to think about using database management software
• Creating a Web presence
• Know the basics
• eMarket your website
• Competitive advantage
• Porter and competitive advantage
• Have the IS department set priorities
• Have a cross-functional steering committee set priorities
• Develop a formal plan for information systems
• Project management risks
• Security risks
• Internet risks
• Summary of IS risk management
• Detecting competitive threats
• Eliminating or lessening surprises
• Enhancing competitive advantages by lessening reaction time
• Finding new opportunities
• Human intelligence
• Fee based companies
• What is an industry?
• Industry structural characteristics
• Concept of strategic groups
• Bargaining power of buyers
• Bargaining power of suppliers
• Threat of new entrants
• Threat of substitute products
• The intensity of competitive rivalry
• Personal ethics: four ethical approaches
• Management: the meta profession
• The paradox of the public pledge
• The paradox of pay
• Corporate Social Responsibility
• Product categories
• Examples of business models from the music industry
• Traditional business model
• Digital music stores
• Open content
• Artist-centered website hub
• Artist’s personal website
• Non-traditional “record labels”
• Tax-the-device model
• Summary of new business models
• Evaluating new products
• Product failure
• Case: “Apples: Newton and Pippin”
• What is globalization? Case: United States Domestic Automaker, Ford
• Elements of economic globalization
• Negative effects of globalization for developing country business
• Positive effects of globalization for developing country business
• Globalization and the small business entrepreneur
• Phone, Fax and SMS
• Technology for the business entrepreneur
• Host country research and cultural implications
• Cross-culture training
• Cultural classification
• Hofstede’s 5 Cultural Dimensions
• Ethical considerations
• What is political risk?
• Forms of investment and risk
• Protection from political risk
• Government policy changes and trade relations China establishes a new employment contract law for 2008 (www.aon.com)
• What is legal risk?
• Political and legal risk for the small business entrepreneur
• Case: Toyota has a vehicle for every market
• What is global marketing?
• The 4 P’S of the Marketing Mix (NetMBA, 2008)
• Importance of culture on markets
• Global branding—creation of a marketing strategy
• Global marketing and the small business entrepreneur
• Exchange rates
• Foreign exchange market
• Introduction to currency risk
• Introduction to derivatives
• International accounting standards board
• Global finance and the small business entrepreneur
• International division
• Global functional structure
• Product structure
• Area/geographic structure
• Matrix structure
• Beyond the matrix
• Staffing choices in a globally far-flung company
• Trends and challenges in a global HR environment
• Corporate Social Responsibility and sustainable development defined
• CSR and corporate strategy
• Case: Built to Last by Jim Collins
• Successful Implementation of CSR and Sustainable Development
• CSR, Sustainable Development, and the Future of Businesses
• CSR and the small business entrepreneur
• Definition and statistics
• Growth models
• Growth through buying out other companies
• Growth through cooperation
• Stopping growth by selling the firm
• Growth through innovation
• Management mistakes
• Incompatibility of growth strategies and organizational structure
• Inadequate or incorrect marketing, cooperation, finance, or HR strategies
• Inadequate or incorrect internal accounting
• Dependence on third parties
• Acculturation problems when buying companies
• References, and further literature
• About the chapter author
• About the chapter editor
•  Back Matter

This action cannot be undo.

Choose a delete action Empty this page Remove this page and its subpages

Content is out of sync. You must reload the page to continue.

New page type Book Topic Interactive Learning Content

• Config Page
• Add Page Before
• Add Page After
• Delete Page

• Harvard Business School →
• Faculty & Research →
• April 2004 (Revised July 2019)
• HBS Case Collection

Wal-Mart in Europe

• Format: Print
• | Language: English
• | Pages: 25

About The Author

Gunnar Trumbull

Related work.

• Faculty Research
• Wal-Mart in Europe  By: J. Gunnar Trumbull and Louisa Neissa

Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

• We're Hiring!
• Help Center

Walmart's Downfall in Germany: A Case Study

Related Papers

Hafez Shurrab

International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management

John Fernie

Elmar Kulke

Cornelia Scott

The year 2020 required many changes in all areas of life as a result of the Covid-pandemic. Both privately and professionally, we had to deal with new challenges. The economy in Germany and especially the in-store retail sector was affected severely by the lock-downs. Small retail businesses are especially threatened because of their low financial reserves and many insolvencies are imminent. This is very dramatic because, on the one hand, many livelihoods are directly linked to these small retailers. On the other hand about 94% of the sectors are currently so called micro or small enterprises with less than 10 or 50 employees and an annual turnover under 2 or 10 million euros. These “local shops” are a characteristic of city centers and important for the economic stability and diversity of the country. To support these businesses, the state has introduced various direct financial aids and indirect ones such as short-time work or guarantees. Regardless of the difficulties associated ...

Guenter Schamel

Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services

Andreas Hemming

Urban Geography

Yuko Aoyama

Environment and Planning A

alan Hallsworth

RELATED PAPERS

Chloe Cheffins

Journal of Dentomaxillofacial Science

Eri Hendra Jubhari

Muscle & nerve

UAS PAPER ETIKA SOSIAL

Adela permata Wibowo

Jezikoslovni zapiski

Maria Wtorkowska

Jurnal Ilmu Komputer dan Agri-Informatika

Karlisa Priandana

edson colodel

Brieuc-Yves Cadat-Lampe

Haematologica

Revista Brasileira de História & Ciências Sociais

Lamartine DaCosta

Jurnal Ilmiah Akuntansi Dan Bisnis

Yolanda Simangunsong

Ivan Valchanov

American Journal of Veterinary Research

Ivan Kalmukov

Quaderni di …

Francesca Forno

Allison Reiss

Atas do ...

Frederico Braida

Douglas Hägerström

International journal of clinical and experimental medicine

Adriana Villavicencio

Marcos Pascoal Pattussi

The Scientific World Journal

Eugene Silow

Journal of mechanics engineering and automation

Ngô Minh Tuấn

The Journal of Immunology

Michel Cogné

Territorios En Formacion

•   We're Hiring!
•   Help Center
• Find new research papers in:
• Health Sciences
• Earth Sciences
• Cognitive Science
• Mathematics
• Computer Science
• Academia ©2024

Why Walmart Failed In Germany

It's a place where you can buy your weekly grocery order and get your prescriptions refilled in one visit. It's a place where you catch up on the local gossip with your neighbor in the cereal aisle or watch a fellow shopper in ill-fitting pajama pants buy a single rotisserie chicken. For all its ups and downs, Walmart is no doubt a genuine American institution. Originally a simple five-and-dime general store in Bentonville, Arkansas — a place that still exists as the official Walmart Museum  – Sam Walton's store has a long history. While you can find a Walmart superstore just about anywhere in the United States, you're probably not going to hear the name if you head over to Europe.

That doesn't mean Walmart didn't try to expand over in Europe, however. In the final years of the '90s, Walmart attempted to bring old-fashioned American productivity, low prices, and efficiency to the German public (via New York Times ). Unfortunately, Walmart had to say auf wiedersehen to its grand plans in the country by 2006. Just what exactly happened that made Walmart abandon its plans? 

Germans simply didn't understand Walmart culture

While we are not vastly different than our neighbors over in Germany, it's safe to say that our customs and culture are not totally alike. Germans are stoic, friendly people who strive for the best in their lives (via LiveScience ), so one would expect that Walmart could thrive as a company that aims to meet all their customer's needs in one store. The reality is that Walmart, with all of its American values, simply didn't fit into German culture. As reported by The New York Times , the worker unions typical in the country were not embraced by the company.

The Global Millennial  detailed three more reasons for the failure of Walmart in Germany. The first reason was that Walmart's "employee motivation training" like team-building exercises outside of the store may have come across as too regimented or too silly. Another issue was that German people were uncomfortable with Walmart employees smiling at them so much. Smiling awkwardly at the cashier in line may have been strange for people who typically reserved smiles for close friends and family. The third reason was due to conflicts with Walmart's ethic codes, which required employees to monitor each other in case of misconduct.  

Whatever the reasons, it was clear that the corporation's American customs did not align with the culture in Germany. Perhaps one day, Germans and Americans can bond over what foods you should never buy at Walmart .

Walmart Company in Germany Case Study

The time when Wal-Mart opened its stores in Germany was marked by complicated economic conditions exacerbated by adverse demographics and strict governmental regulations imposed on store owners. The laws governing general commercial activities were not conducive to opening a retailing business. Regulation of store hours and restrictions on “loss leader pricing” created a highly demanding environment for Wal-Mart (Lascu 162).

Moreover, the company’s distinguished strategy called every day low pricing (EDPL) was deemed illegal and rendered useless their unique selling proposition (Lascu 162). According to the German legislation of that time, in order to put a product into the EDPL category, it should be marketed at a lower price for two months. Furthermore, a long list of retailers such as Aldi and Lidl, Globus, Real (Metro), Kaufland, and Toon (Rewe Group) offered a sound competition for Wal-Mart (Lascu 162). The rivals’ strategy of zone pricing allowed them to outmaneuver the company and block its clear price leadership (Lascu 162).

Wal-Mart failed in Germany because of its inability to properly calculate the risks related to competition that had better geographic penetrability. The company was also mistaken in its belief that the German market is not different from that in the United States. Moreover, the leadership of Wal-Mart was not able to understand the cultural differences between German and American consumers (Lascu 162).

Walmart wanted to use the high quality of service as leverage in competition on the market. The company believed that providing their customers with shopping bags and packing service free of charge would give them a competitive advantage (Lascu 162). They also trusted in the strategy of focusing on low pricing while shifting consumers’ center of interest to the quality of service. However, buyers in America and Germany are different in many significant respects and do not respond to the same incentives (Lascu 162).

Those differences can be described using the Hofstede dimensions. Germans tend to be more individualistic in their purchasing behavior. They are willing to “hunt” for bargains themselves and enormously enjoy the process (Lascu 162). Moreover, in view of German consumers, the store’s offers did not seem cheap but rather created the perception of luxuriousness. This illustrates their difference in the Indulgence vs. Restraint (IND) dimension (Lascu 134). Furthermore, German consumers are loyal to national brands, and it is hard to convince them to switch to other retailers.

Wal-Mart also miscalculated the extent to which the German employee culture differs from that in the United States (Lascu 163). German workers were not willing to accept the American customer-service traditions and, in spite of the encouragement of their managers, did not want to adopt a habit of cheerfully greeting their customers. There also was a massive backlash against the rules prohibiting relationships at work (Lascu 163).

Walmart should have pushed against regulations limiting store hours. Moreover, it would be wise to consider how the two cultures differed across all Hofstede dimensions. Because any discrepancies in power distance index, individualism vs. collectivism, uncertainty avoidance index, masculinity vs. femininity, long-term orientation vs. short-term orientation, and IND can translate into a significant loss of profit (Lascu 134).

Even though the company’s marketing mix was quite effective in the United States, it should have been changed to better fit Germany. Walmart needed to concentrate on better penetrability into local markets. Their element of the promotion mix should have been corrected to reflect the expectations of German consumers better. Wal-Mart should have accommodated their pricing strategy to the existing regulations in order not to lose its EDLP selling point.

Lascu, Dana-Nicoleta. International Marketing (5th ed.). Mason: Cengage Learning, 2008. Print.

• Chicago (A-D)
• Chicago (N-B)

IvyPanda. (2021, August 5). Walmart Company in Germany. https://ivypanda.com/essays/walmart-company-in-germany/

"Walmart Company in Germany." IvyPanda , 5 Aug. 2021, ivypanda.com/essays/walmart-company-in-germany/.

IvyPanda . (2021) 'Walmart Company in Germany'. 5 August.

IvyPanda . 2021. "Walmart Company in Germany." August 5, 2021. https://ivypanda.com/essays/walmart-company-in-germany/.

1. IvyPanda . "Walmart Company in Germany." August 5, 2021. https://ivypanda.com/essays/walmart-company-in-germany/.

Bibliography

IvyPanda . "Walmart Company in Germany." August 5, 2021. https://ivypanda.com/essays/walmart-company-in-germany/.

• Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City' by Robert Dahl
• Wal-Mart's Extraordinary Success
• Wal-Mart Stores Processes
• Wal-Mart’s Innovative Operations & Strategies
• Wal-Mart Strategic Marketing
• Wal-Mart Stores: Comprehensive Analysis
• How Wal-Mart Could Continue Its Extraordinary Growth?
• Wal-Mart Effect on US Economy
• Wal-Mart in China
• Wal-Mart’s Strategy and Structure
• Green Acres Company and GMO Products
• Jet Blue Airlines: Company's Challenges
• Microsoft's Challenges in Office Product Development
• Groupon Company's Information Technology and Competition
• Ford Company's Automobile Dealerships' Work

A Detailed Case Study on Largest Retail Giant Walmart

Avinash kumar mahato

Walmart is one of the largest retail companies in the world. It was founded in 1962 by Sam Walton. The headquarter of this company is situated in the United States. The main aim of the company is to provide consistent discounts, loyal customer service, and fast friendly service.

Walmart’s targets to expand its business in large cities as well as spread retail stores throughout the world. The retail stores of Walmart are divided into four divisions Walmart Supercenters , Discount Stores, Neighborhood Markets, and Sam’s Clubs warehouses. More than 100 million customers are visiting these Walmart Stores.

It is very uncomfortable for small merchants and communities in America. Walmart reaches their town and provides low-cost offers and the best customer service. It is a very bad condition for small merchants and businessmen in America. To downtown merchants, Walmart just comes and takes over all the small stores.

The purchasing power, aggressive marketing and provide low prices to the customer by Walmart, tend to pull out the business by the small merchants. Gradually the dream of Walmart company to become the largest retailer in the world is full filing day-by-day. But, they increase their business by the wrong actions and do not respect the culture or language of the communities.

Timeline Events Of Walmart company Business Model Of Walmart How Walmart Generates Revenue? Walmart’s Marketing Strategy Walmart’s - Flipkart Acquisition

Timeline Events Of Walmart company

The Timeline of events for Walmart company since its inception.

• 1960: Sam Walton opened his first discount store in Rogers, Arkansas.
• 1981: Walmart become the largest company in America .
• 1981: After becoming the largest company in America, they opened their stores in a small Louisiana town.
• 1983: Walmart opened its stores in Pawhuska and Oklahoma.
• 1986: Walmart claims that it can restore more than 4000 jobs to American Communities.
• 1989: They drive a campaign about Environmental awareness that Walmart is aware of land, water, and air.
• 1990: There are some activist groups against the expansion of Walmart’s store.
• 31st December 1990: Walmart’s closed its stores in  Louisiana.
• 5th November 1991: Walmart opened up its store in Lowa City.
• 6th October 1998: Walmart’s founder Sam Walton created a family charity named Walton Family Charitable Support Foundation.
• June 1999: Walmart takes over the ASDA Chain (a British supermarket chain), now they have stores and depots across the United States.
• 2001: Walmart becomes the world’s largest retailer, got huge sales of $191 billion.
• July 2003: Walmart opened its stores in Beijing and till now they have 22 stores in China and counting.
• 2006: Walmart closed its stores in Germany.
• July 2007: Walmart is operating more than 2500 retail units in Walmart International and more than 500,000 employers in some countries.
• 2007: By the ending of this year, they got a net $45 billion sales.
• 2008: Walmart’s opened its wholesale facility in India. This is the first step of Walmart's to sell products through its retail outlets in India.
• 2018: Walmart acquired Flipkart for $16 billion and owned 77% stake in India’s largest online retailer brand.

Business Model Of Walmart

There are different business models that are followed by successful companies which vary from time to time. The business model of Walmart is based to eliminate the middleman from the distribution channels. The advantage of removing the middleman is to provide benefit to the consumer by providing products at lower costs. The main motive of Walmart's business strategy company is to enter every segment of the market and dominate the market by providing products at a lower price.

The main marketing strategy of the company is based on leading on price, be competitive, and deliver a great experience by the motto of Everyday Lower price.

Walmart has three important segments.

Walmart U.S

Walmart U.S is operated in the U.S. They provide customers with products and services that are not present physically in stores. They provide their services via the website and mobile application . The website of Walmart company has a special feature that provides a third party to sell products. The company operates its business on various platforms like supermarkets, discount stores, neighborhood markets, and e-commerce websites .

Walmart International

Walmart International is also divided into three sections which are retailers, wholesalers, and other small projects. These sections are also divided into various sections such as supermarkets, warehouses, electronics, apparel stores , drug stores, digital retailers, and many more.

It is the online platform of Walmart’s company i.e., “ samsclub.com ”. This club is consists of memberships of the only warehouse retailer operations. This section includes warehouse clubs in the U.S, as well as samsclub.com.

Want to Work in Top Gobal & Indian Startups or Looking For Remote/Web3 Jobs - Join angel.co

Angel.co is the best Job Searching Platform to find a Job in Your Preferred domain like tech, marketing, HR etc.

How Walmart Generates Revenue?

The Revenue Model of Walmart deals with the principle of buying in bulk in one go. In this system, they got a huge discount from the manufacturers. They sell in small quantities at low prices. By reducing the price they have high sales volume through which they have high earning.

Walmart’s generate its revenue by removing the middleman and selling their product directly to the customers and services to business. The two main sources of revenue are Product revenue and Service revenue .

Walmart's revenue in the fiscal year ending January, 2020 was $524 Billion.

Product Revenue

Walmart has a wide range of products in various categories:-

• In the grocery category, they have products like Daily needs products, dairy products, frozen foods, bakery, baby products, beauty aids, and many more.
• Health and wellness category have products like Pharmacy products and clinical services .
• The entertainment category has products like electronics products, toys, cameras, movies, music, videos, and books.
• Stationary, paints, and hardware, Automotive, sporting goods, crafts, and seasonal merchandise.
• Apparel categories include apparel for men, women, boys, girls, shoes, jewelry, and accessories.
• Home appliances include home furnishing services, home decor, livings, and horticulture.

Service Revenue

Walmart also provide services to generate revenue in various fields:-

• They provide financial services like prepaid cards , money orders, wire transfer, money transfers, bill payments, and so on.
• VUDU movie streaming services: This is a subscription-based OTT platform for buying and renting movies, watching TV shows on demand.
• Clinical Services include primary health care, Physical and Wellness checks, Clinical lab tests.
• Health Insurance services

Walmart’s Marketing Strategy

Walmart's Business Strategy Analysis is one of the most important parts of any business whether it is small or large. It is very important to make an effective marketing plan to survive in the market . Walmart uses the principle of business marketing penetration method which is used to capture the market by offering lower prices and competitive prices to the consumers.

The company follows cost leadership which makes a huge profit for the company. The company provide low prices to the consumer and treated all the customers as king of the market to maintain the relationship between Walmart and the customer.

According to Walmart, there are four factors that drive the customer’s choice of retailer:

• Assortment.

One more reason for the success of Walmart is purchasing products from local manufacturers in a bulk in one go and selling in small quantities. Buying from local manufacturers is the benefit for both. Buying more products from local manufacturers means they are creating more jobs and they reduce the unemployment rate. They should provide good quality products at a lower price to maintain a good relationship with customers and continue to get profits in business.

List of Courses Curated By Top Marketing Professionals in the Industry

These are the courses curated by Top Marketing Professionals in the Industry who have spent 100+ Hours reviewing the Courses available in the market. These courses will help you to get a job or upgrade your skills.

Walmart’s - Flipkart Acquisition

Flipkart is one of the leading Indian e-commerce brands. In 2018, Walmart takes 77% stakes in India’s largest e-commerce company Flipkart and makes the world’s biggest purchase of an e-commerce company.

After this acquisition the future of eCommerce industry in India has become more competitive than ever.

The three main reasons for the acquisition of Flipkart are Flipkart’s leadership in some lucrative sections, its payment platform and the company’s talent pool.

Walmart’s world’s largest company is to continue to expand its business by improving its strategies day-by-day. The main reason for the success of Walmart is the EDLP system i.e., Everyday Low Price. They are working aggressively to maintain profits, market shares, and provide low prices to consumers. There are many business ideas to gain profit from a market. All depends on how you play the cards for a profitable business.

Walmart has made acquisitions of 28 organizations and has 16 sub-organization.

Feel free to reach us and share your understanding and views on the case study of Walmart. We would love to hear from you.

What is the business model of Walmart?

The business model of Walmart is based on eliminating the middleman from the distribution channels. The advantage of removing the middleman is to provide benefit to the consumer by providing products at lower costs.

What is the motive behind Walmart's Business Strategy?

The main motive of the Walmart business strategy company is to enter every segment of the market and dominate the market by providing products at a lower price.

What is Walmart's Market Strategy?

How does walmart generate revenue.

The earning model of Walmart deals with the principle of buying in bulk in one go. In this system, they got a huge discount from the manufacturers. Walmart’s generate its revenue by removing the middleman and selling their product directly to the customers and services to business.

What are the main sources of revenue for Walmart?

The two main sources of revenue are:

• Product revenue
• Service revenue

Is Walmart owned by China?

The Walmart branch in China is majority Chinese-owned. But predominantly it is owned by Sam Walton's many children.

Why is Walmart so cheap?

They sell in small quantities at low prices. By reducing the price they have high sales volume through which they have high earning.  Hence, by selling in high volume they can sell it at a cheap price and still gain profit.

What are the sub-organisations under Walmart?

There are 16 sub-organisations of Walmart. Some of them are:

• Walmart Labs
• Seiyu Group
• Walmart Canada

What are the top acquisitions of Walmart?

Walmart has acquired 28 companies. Some top acquisitions are:

Must have tools for startups - Recommended by StartupTalky

• Convert Visitors into Leads- SeizeLead
• Payment Gateway- Razorpay
• Spy on your Competitors- Adspyder
• Manage your business smoothly- Google Workspace

Navigating the World of Mobile SDKs: A Developer's Guide

Every app development team consists of tech architecture, UI/UX coding, front and back-end developers, a team of marketers, graphic or motion designers, and quality assurance specialists to ensure the app is running smoothly. Nevertheless, developing a mobile app can take anywhere from a few months to a full year,

Players Who Have Earned the Most Through IPL in the Last 17 Years

Run by the most affluent cricket board in the world– BCCI– the Indian Premier League is among the world’s highest-paid lucrative tournaments. As mentioned by Forbes, IPL is the sixth most valuable sports league in the world, ranking behind the NFL, the Champions League, and Europe’s four big

Indian FMCG Consumer Engagement Revolutionised by AI

The analysis by the global market research firm EY states that consumer goods companies have enormous opportunities to use AI to improve asset tracking, supply chain management, and consumer experience and engagement. The use of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies to improve customer centricity and operational efficiency is on the rise

Empowering India's MSMEs: Navigating the 45-Day Payment Rule

In India, there's a new rule called the 45-day MSME payment rule. It says big companies have to pay small businesses (MSMEs) on time. This is important for small businesses in India because it helps them stay financially healthy and run their businesses smoothly. The 45-day MSME payment rule mandates

• Skip to main
• Skip to footer

You're off the clock!

• Flagship Conferences

Decking the aisles with data: How Walmart's AI-powered inventory system brightens the holidays

Parvez Musani

Sr. Vice President, E2E Fulfillment

Oct. 25, 2023

Empowered by our artificial intelligence (AI)-and-machine learning (ML)-driven inventory management systems, Walmart is primed to deliver one of the most seamless and gratifying holiday shopping experiences for our customers. From sought-after gifts and festive decor to delectable treats, our customers and members can be confident in finding the perfect items to make their holiday season merry and bright.

Our AI-powered inventory management system is essential for supplying customers with what they need, when they need it, and at the low costs they expect from Walmart. By leveraging historical data and pairing it with predictive analytics, we’re able to strategically place holiday items across distribution and fulfillment centers, and stores, optimizing the entire shopping experience. This data management system, along with investments in our supply chain—including automated facilities, department-ready freight, Next-Gen fulfillment centers, and store-based fulfillment—combined with in-store technology used by our associates and our massive last-mile delivery network, also ensures the efficient delivery of items. Our system is more powerful because it integrates insights from all the channels we use to serve customers. As an omni-channel retailer, we analyze both physical and digital sales to deliver our customers with an easy shopping experience over the holidays and beyond.

Combining decades of customer service and holiday inventory management with AI insights

Walmart has helped customers and members celebrate the holidays for more than 60 years by continually advancing our inventory management processes to ensure customers can find everything from coveted gifts to festive treats. In recent years, we have tested and integrated AI/ML models into our systems, complementing our use of historical data to guide the flow of holiday items through our supply chain. Today, our AI/ML engines are  primed to offer even deeper insights and we expect our performance will be stronger than ever.

When building AI/ML frameworks for holidays, we start with a foundation of data and business constraints to create a possible universe of Machine Learning models. During model training, we fine-tune machine-learning models using historical data like past sales, as well as online searches and page views.

We also consider ‘future data’ such as macroweather patterns, macroeconomic trends and local demographics to anticipate demand and potential fulfillment disruptions. With this combined data, our engines identify and correct discrepancies, inefficiencies, or inaccuracies in supply chain models. By the time our customers are ready to shop, our AI/ML data has already completed the heavy lifting to improve inventory flow.

Leveraging a patent-pending capability

While predicting consumer behavior is possible, unforeseen events and their impact on typical purchasing patterns can create added challenges.

However, we do not always want to apply anomalies like a once-in-a-lifetime snowstorm in Florida to our future inventory management process. Instead, our software aims to display demand as closely as possible to historical consumer tendencies and adjustments.

What makes our AI/ML engines so powerful is that they can ‘forget’ such anomalies so that we are not carrying over one-time deviations into future inventory management practices. This will be the first year this capability has been used to help deliver for our customers during the holiday season. 

AI is ‘always on’ and ready to distribute, supply and deliver

Whether customers are shopping in stores, online or using the app, Walmart is able to provide them with the holiday supplies they need, within their reach. Our inventory management systems connect to our 4,700 stores, fulfillment centers, distribution centers and our suppliers. Every interaction and step of the way is measured, captured and used to further train our AI models and machine learning engines.

Our AI-driven systems leverage a variety of factors to determine both quantity and timing of inventory flow, as well as more precisely identify where we distribute. With greater accuracy in our geographic distribution zones, we can understand our customers’ demands down to differentiations by zip codes. For customers enjoying at-home delivery, our systems are optimizing Spark delivery routes to save time from the moment of purchase to their front door.

With state-of-the-art learning systems, we are also adding inputs to help adjust for regional differences in needs, cultures, and buying habits. For example, we will always make sure that pool toys are available in the sunny states, and warmer sweaters are stocked in colder states. Our engines are always learning, so we can optimize, increase demand or reposition inventory to higher selling regions. For instance, if a toy isn’t selling well on the East Coast but is hot in the Midwest, we can reposition inventory or divert the demand. 

Empowering our associates with industry-leading analytics

At Walmart, we are people-led and tech-powered. While our AI-driven inventory systems can offer recommendations, the associate is ultimately in charge. Nobody, and no robot, can replicate the intuition of our associates gained over their careers. Our associates’ feedback is a critical part of the tuning and training process that drives our continued innovation.

As we embrace another holiday season, our associates nationwide have been working tirelessly to deliver exceptional holiday shopping experiences. With our powerful AI-driven inventory system, customers can rely on us to deliver great experiences and savings all season long.

• Ask Walmart
• Privacy & Security
• California Privacy Rights
• California Supply Chain Act
• Terms of Use
• Do Not Sell My Personal Information
• Request My Personal Information